The Ugly Mug Menu in Cape May NJ

The Ugly Mug is a bar and restaurant at 426 Washington Street, on the Washington Street Mall in Cape May, NJ. Below is the menu with prices, from starters, soups and salads to deli sandwiches, burgers, thin crust pizza, seafood platters and a kids menu.

Items, prices and hours can change.

Starters

Made to order starters to begin any meal.

Large Basket of French Fries

$11.99

Large Basket of Sweet Potato Fries

$11.99

Crispy Green Bean Fries

Fried green beans with a spicy pepper panko coating, served with ranch dipping sauce.

$13.99

Vidalia Onion Rings

Beer battered and fried golden brown.

$13.99

Jalapeño Poppers

Breaded jalapeño peppers stuffed with cream cheese.

$13.99

Mozzarella Sticks

Served with marinara sauce.

$14.99

Bavarian Pretzel and Dip

Served with cheese sauce and Düsseldorf mustard.

$14.99

Fried Clam Strips

Served with cocktail sauce.

$15.99

Wings

Choice of buffalo, dry rub Caribbean jerk, garlic buffalo cilantro, mesquite honey BBQ, chipotle BBQ or sweet chili Thai. Served with celery and bleu cheese dressing.

$16.99

Buffalo Chicken Bites

Served with celery and homemade bleu cheese.

$16.99

Chicken Tenders

Crisp on the outside, tender and juicy on the inside.

$16.99

Loaded Beach Fries

French fries topped with melted Monterey Jack and cheddar cheese, chopped bacon and ranch dressing.

$17.99

Beer Battered Popcorn Shrimp

Tossed in your choice of chipotle or buffalo sauce.

$19.99

Fried Calamari

Fresh rings and tentacles sliced thin, lightly breaded and served with marinara sauce.

$19.99

Grande Chicken Nachos

Crisp corn tortilla chips layered with Monterey Jack cheese, chicken and refried beans, then baked. Served with diced tomatoes, black olives and jalapeños on the side.

$20.99

Grande Beef Nachos

Crisp corn tortilla chips layered with Monterey Jack cheese, beef and chili con carne, then baked. Served with diced tomatoes, black olives and jalapeños on the side.

$20.99

Ugly Mug Fries

French fries topped with creamy lump crab sauce.

$22.99

Shrimp in the Rough

Half a pound of large peel and eat shrimp served with cocktail sauce.

$24.99

Colossal Crab Meat Cocktail

Half a pound of colossal crab meat served with mustard sauce and a lemon wedge.

$27.99

Soups and Salads

Homemade soups and fresh salads. Dressing choices are bleu cheese, ranch, Thousand Island, French, Italian, creamy Italian, honey mustard, raspberry vinaigrette, balsamic vinaigrette and oil and vinegar.

Soup of the Day

Cup $7.99

Bowl $11.99

Manhattan Clam Chowder

A recipe handed down for more than 50 years, with a tomato base loaded with littleneck clams.

Cup $7.99

Bowl $11.99

Old Fashioned Chili

Ground sirloin, beans, onions and bell peppers, moderately spiced. An Ugly Mug favorite.

Cup $8.99

Bowl $12.99

The Wedge

Crispy iceberg lettuce, tomato and bacon crumbles with bleu cheese dressing.

$13.99

The Big Garden Salad

Iceberg lettuce and spring mix tossed with grape tomatoes, cucumber slices, olives, red onion and croutons. Add grilled chicken for $9.99, three large shrimp for $14.99 or lump crab meat for $18.99.

$14.99

Caesar Salad

Romaine lettuce, hard boiled egg, grated cheese and homemade croutons. Add grilled chicken for $9.99, three large shrimp for $14.99 or lump crab meat for $18.99.

$14.99

Tuna Salad Bowl

All white tuna, diced red onion, scallions, chopped hard boiled egg and mayonnaise on mixed greens.

$17.99

Chicken Salad Bowl

Diced all white meat chicken with celery and a little mayo on mixed greens with tomatoes, cucumbers and multigrain croutons.

$17.99

Spinach Apple Walnut Salad

Fresh baby spinach, diced red apples, glazed walnuts, red onion, cherry tomatoes and goat cheese with balsamic vinaigrette on the side.

$19.99

Crispy Sesame Oriental Chicken

Crispy fried boneless sesame chicken, mixed greens, mandarin oranges, oriental noodles, toasted sesame seeds, cucumbers and grape tomatoes with an oriental vinaigrette on the side.

$19.99

Shrimp Salad Bowl

Large diced shrimp, chopped green onions and mayonnaise, seasoned and served on mixed greens.

$26.99

Crab Salad Bowl

Jumbo lump crab meat, diced red onion, scallions and mayonnaise on mixed greens.

Market price

Sandwiches and Wraps

Wraps, plus traditional deli sandwiches made with 12 ounces of Carnegie Deli cold cuts. Deli sandwiches come with a pickle and chips on rye, white or whole wheat bread.

Grilled Cheese

Add tomato for $1.99, ham and cheese for $3.99 or bacon and tomato for $5.

$10.99

Liverwurst and Onion

$10.99

Quarter Pound All Beef Hot Dog

Add cheese for $1.99 or chili and cheese for $2.99.

$10.99

BLT

Smoky bacon, iceberg lettuce and tomato.

$14.99

Chicken Salad

All white meat chicken breast.

$14.99

Tuna Salad

All white tuna, diced red onion, scallions and chopped hard boiled egg.

$14.99

Tuna Salad Wrap

Red onions, chopped egg, lettuce and scallions in a flour, tomato or spinach wrap.

$14.99

Turkey and Cheese

$15.99

Imported Ham and Cheese

$15.99

Cheesesteak

Philly style with chicken or beef.

$17.99

Pizza Cheesesteak

Marinara sauce and provolone.

$17.99

South Philly Old Style Pork Sandwich

Slow roasted pulled pork in its own juices, finished with melted provolone on a fresh baked 14 inch sub roll. Served with french fries, coleslaw and spicy BBQ dipping sauce.

$17.99

Turkey Club

$17.99

Grilled Chicken Breast

Served on a kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato and a side of coleslaw.

$19.99

Fried Local Flounder

Served on a brioche bun with a side of coleslaw.

$19.99

Roast Beef and Cheese

$19.99

Hot Roast Beef

Thinly sliced, piled high, smothered in brown gravy and served on a kaiser roll with a side of potato salad.

$19.99

Fried Oyster

Four large local oysters on a brioche bun with coleslaw.

$19.99

French Dip Roast Beef Panini

Thin sliced top round with provolone and Swiss cheese, served with au jus for dipping.

$19.99

Corned Beef and Swiss

$19.99

Reuben

Corned beef, sauerkraut, Russian dressing and Swiss cheese served open faced on fresh baked marble rye.

$19.99

Hot Pastrami

Pastrami, fried onions and Swiss cheese served open faced on fresh baked marble rye.

$19.99

Ocean Shrimp Salad

Large diced shrimp and chopped green onions, lightly seasoned with Old Bay.

$24.99

Fried Cape May Crab Cake

An eight ounce jumbo lump crab cake on a brioche bun with a side of coleslaw.

$28.99

Grilled Cape May Crab Cake

An eight ounce jumbo lump crab cake on a brioche bun with a side of coleslaw.

$28.99

Ugly Mug Lobster Roll Platter

Served with french fries and coleslaw.

$31.99

Maryland Crab Salad

Jumbo lump crab meat, diced red onion and scallions.

Market price

Burgers

Ten ounce backyard style burgers served on a brioche bun with a pickle and chips.

Veggie Burger

Served with lettuce, tomato, onion and a cucumber dill sauce.

$15.99

Hamburger

The classic, with lettuce, tomato and onion.

$15.99

Cheeseburger

Smothered with thick cut American cheese.

$18.99

Cajun Cheeseburger

Coated in Cajun seasoning and topped with cheese.

$18.99

Bacon Cheeseburger

Stacked with applewood smoked bacon and American cheese.

$19.99

Ocean Burger

Topped with homemade shrimp imperial and sharp cheese.

$23.99

Maryland Burger

Topped with jumbo lump crab meat imperial and sharp cheese.

$24.99

Entrees

Platters come with your choice of two sides. Pizzas do not include sides.

Homemade Thin Crust Pizza

$16.99

Homemade Thin Crust Pepperoni Pizza

$17.99

Homemade Thin Crust Bacon Pizza

$17.99

Homemade Thin Crust Margherita Pizza

$17.99

Homemade Thin Crust Sausage and Pepper Pizza

$17.99

Chicken Tenders and Fries

Served complete.

$19.99

Arctic Cod Fish and Chips

Arctic cod fillets hand battered in tempura batter and fried golden brown. Served complete with fries, coleslaw, cocktail sauce and tartar sauce.

$26.99

Grilled Chicken Breasts

Two grilled eight ounce chicken breasts.

$29.99

Whole Lobster

A one and a half pound lobster served with salad, rolls and butter.

$29.99

Fried Shrimp

Shrimp classically breaded and served sizzling hot.

$32.99

Fried or Broiled Flounder

Locally caught flounder.

$32.99

Fried Breaded Oysters

Six Atlantic oysters, shucked fresh, breaded and fried.

$33.99

Baby Back BBQ Ribs

Broiled in a smoky BBQ sauce, with tender pork ribs that pull right off the bone.

$35.99

Broiled Scallops

Half a pound of sweet, juicy sea scallops broiled just right.

$39.99

Fried Scallops

Tossed in house breading and fried golden brown.

$39.99

Fried Cape May Crab Cakes

The chef’s signature recipe, two six ounce jumbo lump crab cakes lightly breaded and fried.

$49.99

Ugly Mug Fried Seafood Combo

Local oysters, sea scallops, local flounder and a crab cake.

$49.99

Sides

Applesauce

$3.99

Coleslaw

$3.99

Pickled Beets

$3.99

Stewed Tomatoes

$4.99

Potato Salad

$4.99

Vegetable of the Day

$4.99

Rice Pilaf

$4.99

French Fries

$4.99

Side Salad

$5.99

Baked Potato

$5.99

Kids Menu

For children 11 and under, served with a kids cup.

Kraft Mac and Cheese

$7.99

Grilled Cheese and Fries

$9.99

Hot Dog and Fries

$9.99

Three Chicken Tenders and Fries

$13.99

Fried Shrimp and Fries

$15.99

Hours and location

  • Address426 Washington Street, Cape May, NJ 08204
  • Phone609-884-3459
  • In seasonOpen daily, 11 am to 2 am
  • Off seasonCall ahead for hours
  • ParkingMetered street parking, meters run April 1 to December 31 from 10 am to 10 pm

About The Ugly Mug

This Washington Street Mall tavern covers lunch on the mall, casual dining and nightlife, seven days a week. The kitchen leans on local seafood, with Cape May crab cakes, local flounder and oysters, alongside deli sandwiches, burgers and thin crust pizza.

Ugly Mug Club history

Look up when you walk in. The mugs hanging from the ceiling belong to members of the Ugly Mug Club, and each member has a personal mug, a custom from the days of vaudeville and barbershop quartets. When a member dies, the mug is hung facing the ocean.

Every September, members and guests gather for a froth blowing contest. Each person gets a glass of beer, and whoever blows the most foam out of the glass is named the United States National Froth Blowing Champion.

The club creed reads, “Mix a little folly with your wisdom, a little nonsense is pleasant now and then.”

The Ugly Mug FAQ

Where is The Ugly Mug?
The Ugly Mug is at 426 Washington Street in Cape May, NJ 08204, on the Washington Street Mall.
What are The Ugly Mug hours?
The restaurant lists in season hours of 11 am to 2 am, seven days a week. Off season hours can differ, so call 609-884-3459 before you go.
What food is on The Ugly Mug menu?
You will find starters, homemade soups and salads, deli sandwiches and wraps, ten ounce burgers, thin crust pizza and seafood platters such as fried Cape May crab cakes, local flounder and broiled scallops. There is also a kids menu for children 11 and under.
Why are there mugs on the ceiling at The Ugly Mug?
Each mug belongs to a member of the Ugly Mug Club, a tradition that goes back about a hundred years. The club holds its froth blowing contest every September.
Where can you park near The Ugly Mug?
Use metered street parking near the Washington Street Mall. The restaurant notes that meters run April 1 to December 31, every day from 10 am to 10 pm.
Does The Ugly Mug have vegetarian options?
The menu does not mark vegetarian dishes, but meatless picks include the Veggie Burger, Homemade Thin Crust Margherita Pizza, Grilled Cheese, Crispy Green Bean Fries and The Big Garden Salad.

Heading to the beach after lunch?

Check the Cape May fly report, beach tags and beach rules before you go.

See the Cape May guide