Published May 18, 2026
If you’re a Jersey Shore local or a first-time vacationer, the unofficial start of summer isn’t just the first sunny weekend — it’s pizza season. Memorial Day Weekend kicks off the Boardwalk, the beach, and the pizzerias that make Ocean City, New Jersey a must-visit Shore destination. We talked to locals, checked reviews, and hit the pavement to bring you this definitive guide to the best pizza on the island.
Quick Answer
The best pizza in Ocean City, NJ includes Manco and Manco (a Boardwalk institution open year-round), Three Brothers from Italy (famous for oversized slices), Prep’s Pizzeria (open since 1965), Roma Pizza (best crust on the island, according to locals), and Chelsea Pizza (the newest fan favorite on Asbury Avenue). Read on for the full list of 12 top spots.
Whether you’re walking the Boardwalk or craving delivery to the beach, these are the pizzerias worth your time and appetite.
Synonymous with Ocean City pizza, Manco and Manco has been a Boardwalk institution for generations. Reviewers love its unique crust and consistently great pies. The 9th Street location keeps locals fed all year long, while seasonal Boardwalk spots deliver that classic Shore-slice experience all summer.
Famous for its super-sized slices and high-quality toppings, Three Brothers is a go-to stop for anyone walking the Boardwalk hungry. Expect a crowd around lunchtime — hit them early or late to avoid the longest lines.
One of the oldest and most beloved pizzerias on the island, Prep’s has been serving crispy, cheesy, gooey perfection since 1965. Longtime fans consistently rank it among the very best on the Shore. Don’t overlook the Dairy Bar — soft serve after a slice is a Prep’s tradition.
Known for its rich, robust red sauce and what many locals call “the best crust they’ve ever had,” Roma Pizza is a seasonal favorite that draws a devoted following every summer. Arrive with an appetite.
After 35 years in Atlantic City, Chelsea Pizza relocated to Asbury Avenue in 2022 and immediately became an island favorite. Reviewers call it “amazing pizza” and praise it for being the best-priced slice on the island. A strong newcomer that has already earned local loyalty.
A reliable takeout favorite at the corner of 15th Street and Bay Avenue, Mario’s is known for consistently perfect crusts and satisfying, well-proportioned slices. Grab a pie to go and find a spot on the beach.
Angelo’s earns fans for its generous portions and plentiful toppings. Beyond pizza, they also serve sandwiches, salads, and pasta — making it a flexible stop for groups where not everyone is in the pizza mood.
For something a step above the classic boardwalk slice, Piccini delivers brick-oven pies made with fresh, seasonal ingredients. Pizza lovers still call it excellent despite occasional wait times and a cash-only policy for in-restaurant dining. Worth it.
Chef-owner Mike Fitzick brings a distinctly different approach to the Ocean City pizza scene: sourdough-based crusts with unique flavor profiles and quality ingredients sourced for seasonality. If you’re open to trying something beyond the traditional Jersey Shore slice, Bakeria 1010 is the spot.
A neighborhood staple on Battersea Road, Express Pizza has been feeding locals for over 30 years. Reviewers praise the crust, and it’s a solid, no-fuss option when you want a reliably good slice without the Boardwalk crowds.
The southernmost pizza destination on the island, Randazzo’s at 34th Street and Asbury Avenue is known for its flavorful Meat Lovers and classic Cheese pizzas. A solid choice if you’re staying on the south end of the island.
A true Boardwalk classic, Pisa Pizza has been serving traditional slices for over 40 years. It’s the kind of place that anchors the Ocean City pizza experience — consistent, familiar, and reliably good.
Popular Boardwalk spots like Three Brothers and Roma Pizza get busy at peak lunch and dinner hours. Arrive early (before noon) or late (after 7 PM) to skip the longest lines.
Several Ocean City pizzerias offer delivery directly to beach entrances. Grab a pie, head to the sand, and enjoy — it’s the most Jersey Shore thing you can do.
Grabbing a box to go — from Mario’s, Express Pizza, or even the Boardwalk spots — and heading to the beach is the classic local move. Less wait, better view.
Even if you have a go-to spot, Ocean City has underrated finds. Chelsea Pizza and Prep’s Pizzeria are worth a visit even if you’ve never heard of them before.
Common questions about pizza in Ocean City, NJ — answered.
Whether you’re walking the Boardwalk, relaxing on the beach, or just craving a slice, Ocean City pizza is woven into the fabric of the Jersey Shore.
Grab a slice, soak up the sun, and enjoy the ultimate Shore tradition.
